Birthday Cake sugar cookie recipe

Birthday Cake sugar cookie recipe

Regular price
Sale price
Regular price
Sold out
Unit price

*Contains box cake mix

Customer Reviews

Based on 8 reviews
Stef Celis

This is my favorite recipe from Sueded Sugar. Which is hard to pick actually. I wouldn't have thought to use those ingredients, but wow do they work so well. It tastes just like birthday cake, has adorable jimmies to make the cookie festive. I saw another say chemical taste, which is not what I have ever tasted with this recipe at all. This is loved by adults and kids, holds it shape perfectly and is an awesome addition to my business!

Rachel Willis
Everyone loves it!

I made these for Easter and not only are they really festive and colorful, they taste Great, too! I'm also using them for Mother's Day! I highly recommend.

Love another recipe I tried, but this one is not it

I have to start by saying that I have liked another recipe I tried, but this one was SO chemically in taste, and did not taste like cake batter at all😔. The texture was good, and I didn’t find the recipe over complicated. I like to give constructive criticism instead of just bashing something. So while this recipe did not have a good taste at all, and was definitely noticed by the dozen people who tried it, I believe it can maybe have hope with some adjustments?

Hi Annabelle!
I am so sorry you didn't like the result of this recipe! I am always up for some constructive criticism! I am wondering if there was something wrong with one of the ingredients used as I have never heard this about his recipe before. It seems strange that even with the cake mix and frosting that it wouldn't taste like cake at all. I know you probably have no interest in trying again but if you ever do, please let me know the results as I would love to know if it turns out any different. And again, I am sorry you weren't happy with the recipe. Please let me know if there is anything I can help with!


elizabeth rodriguez
So Good

literally tastes like birthday cake, will definitely become a go to for future orders.

Kim Lam

Legit my most favorite cookie recipe! So soft and delicious and tastes exactly like birthday cake! perfect for those who'd rather cookies over cake